Minutes of the Planning Committee Meeting held on Monday 16 September 2002 at 7.30pm in the Community Centre Present: RJ Farrington (chair) JE Coston R Day B Jefferson CJ Lock PK Oldham HM Smith RT Summerfield LC Twinn RLE Waters The clerk SJ Daniels 1 Apologies for absence - TJ Siggs 382/02 2 Minutes - the minutes of the meeting of 22 July 2002 were approved and signed as a true record. 3 Decisions Received 383/02 J Crickmore The Stables Chesterton Fen Road - siting of temporary (307/02) chalet accommodation - refused. Conditions: Contrary to Policy SP12/1 of the Approved Cambridgeshire Structure Plan 1995, Policy H5 of the Approved South Cambridgeshire Local Plan (1993) and Policy SE13 of the Deposit Local Plan (as amended 2001) - site is outside village framework for the settlement of Milton and in the countryside where erection of new dwellings will not be permitted unless essential to efficient operation of local agriculture, horticulture and forestry. Within the Cambridge Green Belt and contrary to Policy SP18/3 of the Structure Plan (1995), Policy GB3/1 of the Cambridge Green Belt Local Plan (1992) and Policy GB2 of the Deposit Plan (as amended 2001) - restriction of development to purposes of agriculture, outdoor recreation and other uses appropriate to a rural area. Contrary to Policies SP12/2 of the Structure Plan (1995) Policy C1 of the Local Plan (1993) and Policy EN1 of the Deposit Local Plan (as amended 2001) - site lies in area of best landscape. Would have an adverse effect on the character of the open nature of the landscape. Contrary to Policy CNF6/4 of the Approved South Cambridgeshire Local Plan (1993) and Policy CNF11 of the Deposit Local Plan (as amended 2001) - normally precludes residential development in Chesterton Fen and would create an isolated group of buildings in the open countryside and would not preserve the rural character of Chesterton Fen. 384/02 A West 73 Coles Road - extension. Noted that this application had (330/02) been refused by SCDC Planning Committee. 385/02 Trinity College Unit 181 Science Park - services compound, covered (362/02) cycle racks and 2 roof mounted flues (including amendment to compound) - approved. Details of landscaping scheme to be approved. 386/02 Ms L Collison 10 Garner Close - extension - approved. External (363/02) materials to be identical to those used for existing building. Garage and two car parking spaces to be maintained. 387/02 Mr & Mrs O'Kane 79 Cambridge Road - extension - approved. (366/02) External materials to be identical to existing. 4 New Applications 388/02 S/1672/02/LB Milton Hall Estates Ltd Milton Hall - internal and external alterations and replacement of lean-to conservatory by two storey office extension - no recommendation. Glazing should be in keeping with the existing; construction traffic to use main Ely Road (not Church Lane) entrance. 389/02 S/1673/02 Milton Hall Estates Ltd Milton Hall - demolition of conservatory replacement with permanent office extension - no recommendation. Comments as above. 390/02 S/1719/02 Mr & Mrs AE Dewey 49 Old School Lane - extensions - no recommendation. Any decision should take into account that there is a house at number 51 Old School Lane (not shown on location plan). 391/02 S/1738/02 Mr & Mrs Scarborough 5 Coulson Close - single storey rear and side extension - no recommendation. The meeting ended at 7.55pm.